
Rakyat Pasti Menang
Taring Padi
Taring Padi member Alexander Supartono recounts the stories behind five early banners which played a pivotal role in shaping the collective’s political and artistic identity and practice.
Between 1998 and 2002, the Indonesian collective Taring Padi produced at least twenty-one banners, with sizes ranging from 220 × 170 cm to 760 × 460 cm. The productivity of the collective during this period was driven by the historical urgency and political turmoil of the early Reformasi era following the fall of military dictator Suharto in 1998. Made for outdoor display, these large-scale paintings were intended to attract people’s attention and mobilise them politically and culturally. Realist in style, they are full characters (both protagonists and antagonists), many of whom derive from the group’s experiences as activists. They manifest the collective’s anger towards the systemic corruption and brutal militarism of Indonesian society through scenes of graphic violence, zoomorphic figures, and provocative texts. These banners, as Sarah James eloquently puts it, ‘have little time for political correctness … They want to cause uproar, to offend, to destabilise the status quo because mobilising political action requires this’.1 Like any art that wants to agitate, educate, and organise, they also hold out hope and propose alternatives. Below I recount the stories behind five of Taring Padi’s earliest banners that were instrumental in shaping the methods, themes, and forms that have come to define our work.

Yustoni Volunteero / Taring Padi, Ingin Presiden Baru – Tolak Suharto (Demanding a New President – No to Suharto, 1998). Acrylic on fabric, 150 × 250 cm. Photo taken at a mass demonstration outside Gajah Mada University, Yogyakarta, Indonesia, 11 March 1998.
Ingin Presiden Baru – Tolak Suharto (Demanding a New President – No to Suharto) was painted by Yustoni (Toni) Volunteero (1970–2018), the first president and a founding member of Taring Padi. On the 11 March 1998, Toni and other student activists carried the large black, white, and red banner, painted in a naïve style, to the main square of Gajah Mada University, the largest and oldest university in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. Tens of thousands of people gathered to protest economic hardship and political corruption under Suharto’s military dictatorship. Some protestors carried an effigy of Suharto and set it aflame. After the devasting economic impact of the 1997 Asian financial crisis, Suharto was not at the peak of his power. Nevertheless, after ruling Indonesia for more than three decades, the Grand General still held the nation in his authoritarian grip. Although public criticism of Suharto intensified dramatically after the 1997 financial meltdown, burning his effigy before a sea of people was, in the view of authorities, still considered blasphemous. Toni had to hide for several months from the secret police. This experience led the group to decide not to mention individual names in our collective works for reasons of safety and because we wanted to continue committing political blasphemy.
Another founding member, Mohamad ‘Ucup’ Yusuf, recounts his memory of attending that event: ‘Arya Pandjalu (also a founding member) and I rode together on my beat-up Honda 70 motorcycle with its bamboo exhaust to the demonstration, followed the entire procession, particularly the burning of the Suharto effigy, and our hearts were filled with overwhelming joy.’2 The joy that overwhelmed Ucup and Arya emanated from a sense of anticipation of what could and needed to be done to transform artistic practice into direct political action, and to bring art to the people. In a squatted space located in a former art school building, Gampingan, we discussed the need for an organisation that provided a platform to continue just that: producing large-scale outdoor paintings that could rapidly respond to urgent political demands.

Taring Padi, Rakyat Pasti Menang (People United Will Never Be Defeated, 1998). Acrylic on fabric, 590 × 330 cm.
On 21 May 1998, Suharto was forced to resign. Yet, despite Suharto’s resignation, people were still on the street demanding sociopolitical reform. One of Suharto’s most damaging legacies was the political doctrine of ‘Dwifungsi ABRI’ (dual function of the military), which gave armed forces a permanent role in socio-political governance. Under the New Order regime, this sophisticated implementation of martial law lasted for more than thirty years and was only phased out of national parliament in 2004. It goes without saying that anti-militarism is a foundational pillar of Taring Padi’s artistic and political identity. The very first collective large-scale painting by Taring Padi, Rakyat Pasti Menang (People United Will Never Be Defeated), was created during the anti-militarism euphoria that followed the fall of Suharto’s military dictatorship. The literal translation of the title is ‘People Must Win’, which strikes a note of both hope and caution. The painting depicts protestors marching forward carrying a Molotov cocktail and Indonesian flag, while defeated military figures are depicted with hands tied behind their back. But the real struggle had just begun. As one figure states in a speech bubble: ‘The military (still) monopolise the economy.’ ‘Cabut Dwi Fungsi ABRI!’ (Eradicate the dual function of the military!) is also top of the list of demands.
The banner was made on the spot in just a few hours in June 1998, which explains the unrefined brushstrokes and monochromatic colour. Four (future) members of Taring Padi collaborated with members KPRP (the Committee of People’s Struggle for Change) – the most radical student group in town – hence the inscription of their name in the bottom right-hand corner. Occupying almost one third of the banner is a white panel that had been overwritten several times to serve specific demands for different protests by different groups. Rakyat Pasti Menang anticipates a number of themes and ways of working that continues to underpin Taring Padi’s practice up to the present day, including an emphasis on the use value of art and collective authorship. It was also the first time that we used the term ‘banner’ to refer our paintings, evoking the tradition of banner-making by trade unions for political protests, marches, and strikes.

Taring Padi, Rakyat Demokratik (Democratic People, 1998). Banner on display at the office of Legal Aid Institute in Yogyakarta for Taring Padi declaration, 21 December 1998. Acrylic on canvas, 500 × 400 cm.
On 21 December 1998, the founding manifesto of Taring Padi was declared at the Legal Aid Institute office in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. We chose the office because it was the place where we usually hung out, met before a mass protests, or went to seek help when any of us were detained by police. It was also a statement on Taring Padi’s field of operation, which transcended and continues to transcend the field of contemporary art. For the manifesto reading, we raised the Rakyat Demokratik (Democratic People) banner. In the upper left-hand corner, the banner is graced by the presence of Karl Marx. It is probably the first public display of his face in Indonesia since the mid-1960s, when Suharto led a massive anti-communist purge that resulted in the mass murder of an estimated 500,000 to over 1 million communists. The banner was burnt by a paramilitary Islamic fundamentalist militia in 1999, when we displayed it in the Urban Poor Community Encampment action against militarism in Yogyakarta’s city centre, between 17 and 24 May 1999. The inclusion of Marx marked Taring Padi as a leftist organisation, which was and still is prohibited within the realm of Indonesian politics. Since 1966, Indonesia’s Penal Code has criminalised any activities aimed at spreading or developing the teachings or ideology of communism, Marxism, and Leninism.
Our manifesto contains no verbatim reference to Marxist ideas or any leftist terminologies. The word that can be associated with the left is Rakyat (the people) or Kerakyatan (people-oriented). As we state in our manifesto, we aim to play a role ‘as an umbrella organisation for art workers to encourage all sides to develop local art and culture with a people-minded orientation, based on the needs of the people and the development of a people’s social democracy’. We gravitated toward the Left, finding inspiration in its iconographies, its ideas, and its emancipatory struggles. Our first official name was Lembaga Budaya Kerakyatan Taring Padi (The Institute of People-Oriented Culture of Taring Padi). This name echoes Lembaga Kebudayaan Rakyat/LEKRA (Institute of People’s Culture), a leftist cultural organisation founded in 1950 and closely associated with the Indonesian Communist Party. From 1998 to 2002, we had a rigid organisational structure typical of orthodox left organisations, including a president, a secretary general, propaganda bureau, and ethics committee. The Rakyat Demokratik banner marked the materialisation of our aspirations to live and work collectively and produce art as a political tool using accessible and reproducible mediums, popular idioms, and collective modes of production. It also showcased, for the first time, Taring Padi’s style of social realism: colourful, laden with text, and rich with details that often expresses local humour.

Taring Padi, Pengungsi 2 (Refugee 2, 1999). Banner on display at a solidarity event for Acehnese refugees in Jakarta, 17 July 1999. Acrylic on canvas, 460 × 760cm
Heidi Arbuckle, a founding member and the first scholar of Taring Padi, draws a parallel between the banner Pengungsi 2 (Refugee 2) and the Otto Griebel’s 1928 painting The Internationale, highlighting their similar romantic tendencies in visualising the people.3 The decision to employ a social-realist method and style was based on our desire to use art as medium for propaganda and political mobilisation. We do not necessarily specify realism as Taring Padi’s official artistic approach. In our manifesto, we indicate ‘people-minded orientation’ as a guiding principle in our artistic practice. We agreed that a social-realist style (sometimes interchangeable with socialist realism) was more effective as tool of communication and agitation because it uses recognisable, everyday imagery to create an immediate emotional and conceptual connection. As a consequence, Taring Padi’s members surrendered their individual artistic style to serve this collective objective, a practice that is in line with the ‘no individual name mentioned’ policy that continues to the present day.
Pengungsi 2, as the title suggests, is part of a diptych with Pengungsi 1. Komnas Perempuan (The National Commission on Violence against Women) commissioned these banners. Pengungsi 2 was displayed at the square of the National Monument in Jakarta on 17 July 1999 to raise public awareness of the refugee crisis in Aceh, North Sumatra because of its status as military operation area since 1989. It was the collective’s first commissioned work. This commission indicated a demand for political banners, which Taring Padi enthusiastically embraced. The six banners that Taring Padi produced during this time, which were created within a six-month period, circulated in many socio-political contexts, including a ‘Marxism and the New Millennium’ conference in Australia. This enthusiasm coincided with the growth of progressive left movements in Indonesia following the fall of Suharto.
The procedure for circulating our banners is simple: they travel folded inside a bag or suitcase, without a loan agreement, paperwork, or insurance. Everything is done in the spirit of camaraderie, with the aim of building networks of solidarity and struggle. During Taring Padi’s formative years (1998–2002), this mode of dissemination established the collective’s operational field beyond the contemporary art ecosystem. The Pengungsi 2 banner was left behind on a bus travelling from Semarang to Yogyakarta and was never seen again. This was accepted as part and parcel of our understanding of banners as active and usable tools for education and mobilisation which are open to collective ownership, rather than static art objects. Such collective ownership stretches beyond Taring Padi, whereby everyone is free to use the banner as long as we share the same political commitments. From this perspective, the circulation of banners establishes and nurtures networks between progressive groups and movements.

Taring Padi, Rebut Kembali Hak Rakyat atas Pengembangan Kebudayaan Rakyat (Reclaim People’s Right to a People’s Oriented Culture, 1999). Banner on display at a Scarecrow festival in Delanggu, Klaten, Central Java, 19 December 1999. Acrylic on canvas, 477 × 295 cm.
During the New Order regime, the state systematically disposed rural and indigenous communities. Resisting and unwinding the legacy of these policies became a founding mission of Taring Padi. ‘Land for the people’ (Tanah untuk rakyat), agrarian reform, land-related conflicts, organic farming, and indigenous land rights are recurrent topics in our works. Towards the end of 1999 we produced two banners: Tanah adalah Hidup Kami (Land Is Our Life, 500 x 400 cm) and Rebut Kembali Hak Rakyat atas Pengembangan Kebudayaan Rakyat (Reclaim People’s Right to a People’s Oriented Culture). We made the former in Yogyakarta and sent it to farmers and agrarian reform activists in Kerawang, without visiting them on site. The latter we created when we stayed with an organic farming community in Kranggan village, Delanggu, a three-hour drive from our studio. Both banners went missing in action, but the distinctive processes of their making set a precedent for Taring Padi’s working methodology for years to come. In particular, the practice of learning, living, and working together with communities on a long-term basis became an essential part of our creative process. Direct engagement with workers, peasant, fishing, indigenous, and artist communities, as well as forming diverse ad hoc political alliances, continues to be foundational to Taring Padi’s cultural and political activities.
The first example of such an engagement occurred in October 1999 when Taring Padi participated with farmers in protesting the reintroduction of previously banned pesticides by producing carboard puppets in Yogyakarta. Taring Padi decided to continue the collaboration with farmers in the Delanggu district because it is historically renowned for the best rice variety: Rojo Lele. The village is also home for metal workshops that produce farming tools, including sickles. The area was also a base for the Indonesian Communist Party who suffered horrendously during the 1965–66 anti-communist pogrom. Rice, the Left, and the sickle made for an ideal combination, considering the collective’s name (padi means rice Indonesian) and ideological inclination. While producing the banner, we also organised a scarecrow competition, with the intention of installing the scarecrows in the rice fields. However, the timing was off: the rice grains had not yet ripened enough to attract the birds that the scarecrows were supposed to scare away! This experience explains the banner’s moniker: the Scarecrow Banner. It serves as a reminder of the mistakes we can make when working for and alongside the people. Taring Padi’s commitment to artistically producing tools for political action and mobilisation requires continuous learning from the people. Politics is the purpose and art is the tool, and the tool must never be mistaken for politics itself.